Hnub Monday, lub xam kav tias qhov tseeb pheej nrhiav tau lwm lub sij hawm ib tug tub ceev xwm tsis raws cai nres tej zaum tseem yuav siv hauv tsev hais plaub – nrog rau qhov tias cov neeg khiav dej num ua lawv nrhiav tom qab kev kawm uas yuav tau cov nyaj ib koj ntes warrant caveat. 5-3 lus txiav txim, tus xub ntxiv pom muaj tias zoo li no luag tshawb tsis yuam cov plaub kev pauv.
Rooj plaub, Utah v. Strieff, txhawj Edward Strieff, uas nyob rau xyoo 2006 hlis ntuj nqeg yog nres rau ntawm ib tug neeg khiav dej num staking tawm ib tsam tshuaj-soj ntsuam txog qhov chaw nyob hauv qab ntsev pas dej. Rau lub tsheb tau muaj tom qab kav tsis txaus sai tam sis vim nws twb tsis nyob rau cov ntseeg. Thaum lub tsheb, cov neeg khiav dej num khiav ib daim tshev thiab pheej nrhiav tau lwm Strieff muaj ib tug ntawv tso koj lub tsheb me yuam cai thiab ua ib tug tshawb — nrhiav ib tug baggie tag nrho methamphetamines thiab cov yeeb nkab uas yog tswv ntsawv. Lub tsev hais plaub hauv koog tsev kawm ntawv tom qab ntawd kav tias txawm tus cop tsis muaj txoj cai kom txhob Strieff, cov pov thawj yog admissible. Lub tsev hais plaub ntau tshaj yog nyob rau lub teb chaws muaj tam sim no pom zoo.
Kev ncaj ncees Sonia Sotomayor sau tau ib scathing tsis yeem lus hais txog qhov kev txiav txim hais tias tus nab "qhia sawv daws, dawb thiab dub, tu siab thiab ♦... uas koj lub cev no yuav muaj kev ntxeem tau thaum uas tsev hais plaub excuse qhov txhaum dhau cai ntawm koj txoj cai."
Sotomayor tseem tawg lossis dam tias ib co yog feem ntau yuav muaj nyob rau ntawm qhov kev txiav txim dua lwm tus.
Nws "Yog tsis muaj daim card tias tib neeg muaj tawv dub no disproportionate cov neeg raug dag hais txog hom scrutiny," sau tau.
Tsis yeem lus Sotomayor lub chaw Justice Department qhia txog ntawm cov hauv paus hniav Ferguson riots thiab phau ntawv Michelle Alexander The tshiab Jim uab lag, txiv Ta-Nehisi Coates ntawm lub ntiaj teb thiab kuv thiab James Baldwin 1963 classic The hluav taws lwm zaus.
Activists txog koj txoj cai tau aghast ntawm qhov kev txiav txim.
"Peb tau chim nrog lub hnub txiav txim," John Mejia, raws li txoj cai cov thawj coj ntawm cov pem Yuthas American Civil fwj npe, hais rau koj qhov chaw KUTV. "Tub ceev xwm yeej xav tau rau koj lawm. Ntawm lub hauv paus yog ib txwm mus yog koj muaj txoj cai tsis pub tsoom fwv cuam tsis tau kev tso cai yog cov tsoom fwv yuav articulate tias koj pab vim lawv nyob nraum uas."
